Connexion
/ Inscription
Mon espace

School holiday breaks affect global stock returns according to new research from the MIT Sloan School of Management

ER - Acteurs du secteur financier
ABONNÉS

Lower returns attributable to traders being collectively ‘less attentive’ during vacations 

 

It’s no secret September is a terrible month for stocks. According to a Wall Street Journal analysis, it’s the only month that shows average declines over the past 20, 50, and 100 years. But while the “September Effect” is widely known, no one has come up with a plausible explanation for what causes it.

Enter new research by MIT Sloan School of Management Visiting Prof. Lily Fang. She proposes a simple explanation for the September swoon: school vacations.

“What we see in September reflects a broader ‘after holiday effect’ whereby market returns after major holidays are significantly lower than at other times,” she says. “The lower returns are exacerbated in September because during the long-duration school holiday that precedes it—summer—professional investors are collectively less focused on news and as a result, information is incorporated into stock prices more slowly.”

This effect is particularly strong for negative information because taking advantage of negative news by, for instance, short-selling, is more difficult and requires close attention—a scarce resource in July and August. “Think about how traders spend their summers. They’re on the beach with their kids. They’re traveling overseas with their friends. They’re rightfully enjoying the holidays and as a result not paying as much attention to market news,” she says. “This means that news released during the holidays gets incorporated into prices more slowly than other times. And after holidays, we see that delayed reaction. It is on average negative because bad news travels slowly. It is more difficult, and requires even more attention, to take advantage of bad news than good news.”

Fang and her colleagues—Chunmei Lin at Erasmus University and Yuping Shao at National University of Singapore—compiled and examined school holiday data from 47 countries around the world. They discovered a striking pattern: returns are on average 1% lower in the months after major school holidays. Importantly, this lower return was not driven by September alone, even though the September effect is pervasive in the northern hemisphere. Even when September is excluded, there is still a return gap of at least 0.5% between after-holiday months and other times, and the difference remains highly significant.

To determine whether this disparity is indeed an “after holiday effect” rather than a spurious result, the researchers conducted a number of validation tests that exploit variations in school calendars. For example, in many states in the US, the school year starts in September; but in some southern states, the school year begins in early August. For stocks headquartered in these states, Fang’s team found that August, rather than September, exhibits especially low returns.

“The main lesson here is that attention is a limited resource,” says Fang. “We make the unrealistic assumption that since traders are professional investors, they are super machines with infinite attention spans. But the fact is: human beings are human beings.”

The Nobel Prize winning economist Daniel Kahneman wrote that: “attention is a scarce cognitive resource,” she adds. “Our research clearly speaks to that and shows professional investors are not immune. If anything, our study demonstrates the importance of professional investors in maintaining the efficiency of the markets and in the so-called ‘price discovery’ process.”

* School Holidays and Stock Market Seasonality; Lily Fang, INSEAD and MIT Sloan School of Management, Chunmei Lin, Erasmus University, and Yuping Shao National University of Singapore

Lily Fang is Visiting Associate Professor of Finance at MIT Sloan School of Management

 

Lire la suite...


Articles en relation

ER - Acteurs du secteur financier
ABONNES
Un tiers des fonctions finance a fait l’expérience de la robotisation

La suite Office dans les années 90, le déploiement d'ERP au début des années 2000, puis la réorganisation massive avec appel à l'externalisation, ou encore à la mise en place de Centres de Services Partagés, la fonction Finance a fait l'objet, en effet, de vagues successives de transformations  En France, l'année 2018 a confirmé un intérêt fort du marché de la RPA (Robotic Process Automation) qui continue de se structurer avec des acteurs qui réussissent des levées de fonds record. Mais où en...

ER - Acteurs du secteur financier
ABONNES
Ecofi Investissements se convertit au tout ISR

Tous les supports qui composent la gamme de fonds ouverts d'Ecofi Investissement sont aujourd'hui gérés avec les critères de sélection ESG de l'investissement responsable et de l'investissement durable.   Trois niveaux d'intensité Pionnier de la gestion ISR en France, Ecofi Investissements, filiale du Groupe Crédit Coopératif (lequel est constitué du Crédit Coopératif, banque de référence de l'économie sociale et solidaire depuis plus de 120 ans, et de BTP Banque, établissement dédié depuis...

ER - Acteurs du secteur financier
ABONNES
Nominations Secteur Patrimoine & Finance

Michel Dinet, Directeur du Développement de Richelieu Gestion Agé de 53 ans, Michel Dinet rejoint l'équipe dirigée par Christophe Boulanger, Directeur Général de Richelieu Gestion, qui déclare « […] L'arrivée de Michel traduit la volonté affirmée de Richelieu Gestion de donner une place centrale aux acteurs de proximité de l'épargne dans son développement. Fort de sa connaissance très fine de leurs attentes, de sa volonté permanente de traduire leurs besoins en solutions, il sera un...

ER - Acteurs du secteur financier
ABONNES
PATRIZIA étend son réseau asiatique avec l'acquisition de Kenzo Capital Corporation

Partenaire mondial du secteur de l'investissement immobilier paneuropéen, Patrizia Immobilien AG a acquis les activités de Kenzo Capital Corporation, société de conseil en immobilier et de gestion d'actifs basée à Tokyo, ainsi que les activités relatives à la direction du fonds de Kenzo Japan Real Estate GmbH. Cette étape importante vise à développer le réseau international de Patrizia et à offrir des opportunités d'investissements européens à un nombre de clients toujours croissant, tous pays...